Something in the Water

Something in the Water

I didn’t know what to do with Derek’s remains. I hated people who displayed urns on their mantle pieces like trophies. Also, our house didn’t have a fireplace; it had a television set. I could have put the urn on that but it might have slipped off the sloped back, and what a thing for our son to see over his Saturday morning Cocoa Puffs. I didn’t want to dispose of it at the service, though, because -- well, it seemed morbid, I supposed, or something like that, to treat what came down to intimate garbage disposal like a prop in a circus performance. The Magical Derek Eats Fire And Escapes This World.

So after talking it over with his mother and my son the Tuesday following my husband’s death, I walked to the riverside carrying a balsawood box provided by the crematorium. Nice and poetic. And in the shadow of a bridge I crouched down and flipped it over so that the lid fell open. The ash slumped out in a mess of dead matter after I tapped the bottom twice.

It dusted my fingers with gray, hit water without a sound, barely breaking the scummy surface. The spill had been so fast, but the sink was so slow, as if through tar or treacle, flakes lowering by merciless degrees.

I brushed myself off and leaned over the curb, the better to watch him ripple away.

It would have been a long wait at that pace of dissolution, but the rain started and the water sealed itself up. I told myself that if he was still there after the rain his presence would have to be measured in parts per million, in saturation constants, not in something I could hold vigil over, so I got to my feet.

By that time my short hair was as wet as the knees of my jeans: strands of it clung to my cheek unpleasantly, scattering droplets. I tucked the strands behind my ear, but the droplets stretched into cold lines, and the muscles of my face ached under my clammy rain-pinstriped skin, which felt like it might have congealed into a papier-mâché mask while I was waiting.

I thought: I do not want the mess of a face that I saw in the mirror this morning caked on my bones like plaster, but rubbing at the lines with the heel of my palm made my wrist numb.

Besides -- sometimes, after a shower, he’d dragged his wet bitten nails diagonally from the corner of my mouth to the edge of my ear while I settled against his side. Surely the analogue, lines to lines, counted for something, was worth something.

I thought: I do want to hold details of him like that in place, to sew his past to my eyelids; but the memory, so startling in its clarity, was already fading.

Two unfulfilled wants, those thoughts, curling somewhere in my gut. Maybe they hurt: wobbling, familiar pains. I wasn’t too concerned, I was happy to keep my eyes raised to the high shop fronts, the peeling white paint and pinkish gray stone of the city’s upper levels, and I walked home in the rain, not listening to the echoes in my empty head.

Our son was in the living room where I’d left him, eating slices of cold salmon from the funeral reception while my mother-in-law threaded her fingers through his thin fair hair. She was trembling and William’s head bobbed up and down like a toy, but he didn’t seem to mind.

They were watching a commercial for expensive shampoo, and they’d slid off the faded sofa and onto the floor, piled up against the foot of the coffee table, far too close to the screen.

“Hey, you two,” I said, turning on the light because shadows crowded the room with story-tale grief, although the humming of the fluorescent bulbs almost made me wish I hadn’t. William looked at me with his big frog eyes, pupils surprised by the shine. The rims of iris were too thin around those darkness-swollen pupils to resemble his father’s, though I knew William’s were the same pale blue, the color of deoxygenated blood.

There was a scrap of salmon skin on his lower lip, dark patterned brown against smooth pink. “Hi, Mom,” he said, and sucked it off, a flash of milk teeth.

His grandmother said “Adelaide,” like it was a greeting. She’d liked my name when Derek first brought me home. Such a pretty name, she’d said.

She looked dead, much deader than her son did before I had him burned. Her face fallen in, a false partition that had hid a space cluttered with unwanted secrets. She‘d stolen my son’s blanket, which was probably why he was hugging his knees. He hadn’t changed out of the flimsy blue shirt he’d worn for the reception, either.

“You all right, honey?” she said, sitting up, hand still on him. “It’s done?”

I wanted to tell her to get out, to stop caressing my son‘s skull. Gently, so gently, I said, “I’m all right. I… said goodbye.” Again. It came as news to me, that there was so little finality to funeral rites. Just a series of small deaths.

“That’s fine. That’s just fine. It’s what he would have wanted, you know. Maybe he’ll make it all the way to the ocean, huh? Wouldn’t that be nice?” she said, apparently to William. “The circle of life. Have you seen the Lion King, Will?” She was one of those who believed that most important lessons could be taught via Disney animation.

“Yes,” he said.

“Did you like it?”

“Yes. I liked the part with the bananas, and the big flaming balls of gas.”

“It’s almost five,” I said, a little louder.

“Oh.” She let the blanket slither off her. It uncurled like a fat caterpillar. William edged away. “I should get back to the hotel. Richard will be waiting.”

“Yes,” I said, and helped her up, patting her on the back when she was vertical. Her shirt was weirdly sheer, and the callused stretch of skin between my thumb and forefinger caught on the fabric as I steadied her. I’d meant to squeeze her narrow shoulder, but I didn’t like that catching roughness. Instead I gave her a quick, awkward, one-armed hug.

“Thank you for taking care of him for me, Mary,“ I said. Even I wasn’t sure if I was being ironic.

She stank of soap, detached herself from my ribcage reluctantly when I withdrew.

“It was nice,” she said. “You should send him to see me more often. He looks so much like Derek.”

“I know,” I lied. “And I will.”

“I’m right here,” William whined.

“Yes you are,” she told him, and bent to kiss him on the forehead, thin mouth hollowing in a loving O that blew his bangs up, that did not leave any shining mark. “And we are all glad for that. Stay safe, darling.”

She unbent to kiss me on the cheek. “We’ll both be by tomorrow morning to say a proper goodbye before our flight, Adelaide.”

I nodded and clasped her hand. “Stay for brunch,” I said, because my husband would not have asked me to, because I would have done it for him. Habit like a second mind, a second mouth, which was just as well because my own faltered like I breathed, often and desperately.

“We certainly will,” the old woman said, and walked out door I‘d left hanging open when I stumbled in, which she closed behind her, conscientious. She was the kind of woman who had never had a library fine and I envied her precise, fidgety recollection, her exact grief.

William scooted over to me and hugged my leg as soon as we heard the latch snick shut. “I don’t want to go to Grandma’s,” he mumbled, pressing his face against my jeans. My shins were bruised from kneeling and his sharp little nose hurt, but I was glad not to be alone in my unreasoned dislike: so I picked him up, although he was eight years old and surprisingly heavy for all that his delicate bones almost poked through the thin flesh of his wrists.

He relocated his face on my collarbone, unperturbed by the altitude change, and snuffled against the hollow at the base of my throat, while I shifted his weight so that he was sitting over my arm. I rocked him sideways, his toes skimming back and forth across my thigh.

“You don’t have to go to Grandma’s,” I murmured, kissing the top of his head. Another time I would have made disapproving sounds and swatted him, but if there was ever a time to indulge him and me, it was now, right? Now, when I could feel his heart stuttering through his concave chest.

“Thanks,” he hummed; I felt it more than I heard it, vibrating through my ribs. He seemed content to stay suspended. I was starting to feel like a set of monkey bars, though -- a sore set of monkey bars -- and he was milky-sour in my nostrils, I could see traces of sweat on his folded eyelids. There was indulgence, and then there was indulgence, although it took me a minute to work out what it was I had to do about his filthiness, a practicality that forced its way through the fog.

“You need a bath, kiddo.”

His mouth slanted unhappily while I rubbed circles between his shoulder blades and made a beeline for the stairs. “But Dad gave me baths,” he said, which was true, which was why I hadn’t remembered before. It might or might not also have been a clever ploy to escape the unwanted ministrations but either way it paused me there, on the bottom step.

My husband had liked washing things: dishes, windows, countertops, kids. He’d kept bathing William long after he should have, really, claiming that he never got to spend time alone with him, otherwise. He babied William. We’d argued about it. And I wasn’t sure that it was okay to recall the late-night arguments, the jittery words and broken dishes, that it was okay to use the fact of his absence to do it my way. If I even had a way. Christ, I hadn’t washed dishes since college. I’d never washed William at all, not even when he was nursing -- that was when I gratefully passed him over to his father. I wasn’t even sure I remembered where to scrub. Behind his ears? Hadn’t scientists proved that scrubbing behind the ears damaged hearing, years ago?

The boy had pulled away. He stared at me, trembling with the complex, helpless defiance of small children.

I stared at him, trembling with something else entirely, and backed up against the wall and slid down until I was slouched across several blessedly carpeted steps and William was sprawled over me, his round arms wrapped around my waist, chin digging into my belt. I closed my eyes for a while. There was a headache coming on, a pounding knot in the hollowed bone above my right eyebrow.

“Sorry,” William mumbled, when I opened my eyes.

“It’s okay. Let’s get you cleaned up, huh? You might have to help, since Dad isn‘t here. Can you do that?” Can you tell me how to wipe off all this grief, I asked, with my fingertips. I doubt it carried through his downy skin.

“Yeah,” he said, scrambling to his feet. “I can take a bath by myself, even. Honest.” I eyed him dubiously. “I was only being silly.”

“Thank you, William,” I said. He straightened up and balled his left fist and tried to salute, the gesture sharp and ludicrous. “You know I’m proud of you.“

His eyes were fever-bright, and he shrugged at my intent expression, looked down at his socks. Blushed. That fragile stain of veined red, so lovely. He was paler than either Derek or I had been as children, paler and more inclined to embarrassment.

I looked at our worried son and climbed after him when he trotted upwards. The back of his head was silhouetted against the light of the landing, and it rose like a balloon.

He was stripping down when I caught up with him, pants pooling lopsidedly on the broad tiles. His left foot caught in the tangled trousers, he stood balanced on one leg as he kicked at stiff corduroy, mouth bunched up. He seemed reluctant to finish stripping off any one garment; he moved anxiously, unfocused, trying to undo his buttons and free his foot at the same time.

I stopped his small bird hands and said, “Let me help you with that.”

He flinched.

“I told you I can do it, Mom.”

“I know you can,” I said, sketching nervous nonsense patterns like fish on his breast pocket with my twitching fingers as I dropped to his level. “But you don’t have to do it all.”

“Dad’s gone,” he started.

“And I‘m not,” I finished, before he could shatter my delicate equilibrium.

He nodded, and let go of his collar. He didn‘t say anything more in all the minutes I spent undressing him. It was warm and bright in that small oddly-shaped roomful of porcelain and polished brass, and I could see the goosebumps on his calves, delineated by heavy gold light.

“Why don’t you put on a towel while I run the water,” I said, carefully.

He did. The towel was too small for him, hanging like a poncho; it didn’t cover his skinny legs, but he didn’t shiver, and seemed content to perch on the closed toilet seat, drawing the rough cloth up to his chin. He looked like a moth, huddled under milky wings. I ran the water.

When he did speak up, it wasn’t what I’d expected.

“Where’d Dad go?” he said, as I rolled up my sleeve and dipped my arm elbow-deep the hot water, luxuriating in how the warmth blotted out the soreness.

“Somewhere nice,” I said wearily, hating myself a little. “Heaven. Didn’t your grandma talk to you --”

“Not that,” he said, dismissing cupids and clouds and sugar-sweet metaphysics with a shrug. “The ash. After you put it in the water. Where’d it go?”

“I don’t know,” I said. “What do you mean?”

He said with an air of much-tried patience, “Grandma said it would go to the ocean, but Mrs. Lewinsky --”

“Who?”

“My geography teacher. She said that the river goes to the reservoir, it doesn‘t end up at the ocean at all. So that can’t be right.”

“Oh.” He’d been wondering about that since she’d left? “So it’ll end up at the reservoir.”

“Okay. Mom?”

“Yes?”

“What’s the reservoir, again?”

I stuck my other arm in the water, too quickly, viciously, because I wasn’t sure how many more questions I could take. He was staring up at the ceiling, and he didn’t pay attention when I pulled back as quickly and sucked on my knuckles. I added cold water until I suspected any more would make it lukewarm. “You can get in now,” I said.

He hopped off the seat and padded over, pausing for just long enough to let me bundle the towel away before easing in. There was no hesitation. It was hard to tell whether that was because he trusted me or because he was eager to prove -- something.

“Is this okay? Do you want me to stay?” I said, while he lay back.

“I can do it,” he said, but continued speaking when I pushed myself to my feet. “So what’s the reservoir?”

I sighed. “It’s a man-made lake. Like Crystal Springs. Reservoirs are where we get tap water. We went for a walk there once, you remember.”

“Yeah,” he said, smiling a little. “Okay. We could go again?”

“Yes, we could. You‘d like that?”

“Yeah.”

The silence bloomed around that secret curve of a smile, reshaping the slack contours of his face. He glowed like a deep-sea jellyfish, there in the water, glowed like walking around an artificial lake would bring his father back.

“Will you be okay?” I said.

“Yeah,” he said, not turning his head from where it was pillowed on a wash-cloth. “You don’t have to stay.”

“Maybe I should.”

He blew on the calm lovely green water, the color of glass viewed at a slant, and his reflection turned glassy as it fell apart, then vanished. But in that instant of distortion, the mirrored face elongated, and the wet mirrored hair was dark blond, almost someone else’s brown, and the mirrored eyes were very blue.

“Tap water,” he said. “Is this tap water?”

“Yes.”

“Tap. Water.”

He gazed at me in mute horror and I understood what he was picturing, the nightmare he’d conjured to fend off a far realer horror. I understood, yeah. Maybe too quickly, as if I'd been pregnant with the idea, desperate for it to be articulated, cut out of me. That old guilt.

“William, there are filters they use before any water leaves the reservoir. You are not washing with your father’s ashes,” I said, slowly, enunciating each word so that I would hear.

“I know that,” he muttered. “I’m not stupid. I just -- I don’t know. I thought maybe. His… ghost. Maybe he’s not gone.”

And he was waiting, brimming with the question.

“There is no such thing as ghosts,” I said (to myself).

I had to catch my breath out in the hallway. I had to cling to the paneled wall, a leaf betrayed by wind and sudden frost, thrown off-guard by just how much I wanted to live that fantasy. Ghosts. For god’s sake. Apparently I was desperate enough for Derek that it didn’t matter if he was present only in the water, as long as he was there.

“I can’t do this,” I said to the landing as I descended. The landing made no reply.

Downstairs, in the kitchen, I glared at the dirty dishes, stacked like moons in the shade of a raised cabinet. I filled the oversized mug he’d once made his morning coffee in with tap goddamn water, thank you very much, and drank too deeply.

Please, I thought, choking down liquid that overflowed from my sore mouth.

Two observations:

The hard swallow tasted quite ordinary but for a sweet edge of regret.

When I threw the cup at the wall, it cracked. Sounded like ripping silk. I watched the dust settle for two minutes and seventeen seconds. Then I watched the treacherous light glitter off glazed ceramic and linoleum and water spreading across the sticky floor for exactly eleven minutes more.

And then I went back upstairs to knock on the door, an apology in my knuckles if not my voice.

“William,“ I said, “are you ready to come out?”

“I guess,” he called, though I came in to find him still rinsing out his hair; I glimpsed streaks of shampoo, white lace on his hairline, blending in with the translucent blond roots. Eventually he wiped that off with his thumb, and turned to greet me with a small gleaming face.

“All done?” I said. I was shaking.

“What?” he said, water dripping out of one ear.

“I said, all done?”

“Yeah.”

“You should get out now. The water will get lukewarm, and then you’ll catch cold.”

“Okay,” he said, and obeyed. “I’m sorry I said that. About ghosts. I was sad, that’s all.”

“I know,” I said, handing him the towel. “You don’t have to say sorry. I was upset, but not at you. Never at you. What a stupid thing to get upset over, right? Tap water.”

He dried off while I pulled the plug and watched water spiral down the drain.

In our room, later still, I lay on the unmade bed and tried to find whatever peace William had seen in the ceiling. I counted three stains there, where the brownish water damage was shaped like other worlds, and thought of the one damp spot on my pillow, which was shaped like my skull. I’d taken my stiff jeans off, and my jacket, with its zipper that dug into my stomach where my shirt had ridden up, and its sleeves rolled tight around my elbows. I’d even put aside the towel hanging off me. Discomforts so familiar, so reliable, that it was a shock to find I could rest without them, could disintegrate into a shallow sleep, sand in my eyes, the insectile clatter of rain on the roof in my ears.

Drowsing, I thought: Reservoirs. They’re where we get tap water. And bathwater.

But rain, too.

Drowsing, I dreamed:

“I love you, I love you, I love you,” I said. Derek leaned forward and kissed me on the forehead.

“I’m melting,” he said. And he was.

When I woke, the sky was gray and pale in contrast with the cool fat darkness of the bedroom. I touched the center of my forehead. My fingertips came away wet. I reached over, pulled the lamp-cord, and glanced up to see a leak overhead.

Comments & reviews · 11
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
Silversun
Review

Wow, that was a very touching story. I'll have to say that maybe the narrator should be a little more sad at sometimes, like choking back tears or something, but other than that I thought you did an amazing job at expressing emotions.

Maybe I missed something, which I probably did since it's kind of late, but I'm not exactly sure why they didn't like the Grandmother so much. Perhaps a little more explaining is in order?

Also, a part that really caught my attention was when the little boy saluted. In my mind, that was a touching moment. :) It really showed how people can stay strong after something rocks their world.

Like this story...which rocked my world. Congrats :)

User avatar
fairygirl
Review

Wow great job!! This was a fun read! I dn't have anything to really crituiqe sinc eyou did such a good job!! Keep it up, I'm excited to see what happens next!! :D
~*~fairygirl~*~

User avatar
KJ
Review
KJ wrote a review · Tue Jul 28, 2009 9:40 pm

Hey, I'm KJ. Honestly, I'm not in the nitpicky mood, so I thought I would just tell you what I really enjoyed about this piece. You ready? Here goes: The beginning and the title. Both just immediately caught my attention. Your descriptions and dialogue are also satisfying and enjoyable. You have a gift, my friend, and never stop using it!

So that wasn't very constructive, was it? Well, at least I boosted your ego a little bit, right? I'm glad you wrote this, and I hope you keep on writing.

Your friend,

KJ

User avatar
Kylan
Review
Kylan wrote a review · Sat Jul 25, 2009 1:28 am

Hey Mickey,

This is quality stuff. I was very impressed. You manage to capture this scene with such feeling and grace and experience. The little details, the characterization, are things that I am extremely jealous of. I'm in the process of learning the ropes of those things -- to be able to record exactly how normal people think and feel, or how to make mundane things, like picking up a child, seem beautiful and relatable. I noticed how vastly different your fiction is from your poetry. Your poetry is fantastic, but your fiction goes beyond that. It is very real. I want to see more of it.

Needless to say, I don't have much to comment on. I thought that maybe the kid was a little to coherent and stable and bright for his age -- I think a five year old would handle the death of his father a little differently than how you portrayed it here (perhaps with more denial/ spoiledness/ defense mechanisms), but I've met some real keen, pretencious five year olds before, so... Not a big problem.

Another thing was that it's possible that /maybe/ you dragged things out a little much. I think that this piece could use a little trimming here and there, removing some excess weight. Try to cut the word count down by 5-10%, just to make things a little tighter. Then again, this is the kind of piece that relies very little on plot, and very heavily on feelings and setting, so... Again, not a big problem. Just consider it.

I thought: I do not want the mess of a face that I saw in the mirror this morning caked on my bones like plaster, but rubbing at the lines with the heel of my palm made my wrist numb.


Like Hannah said, this part was confusing, but I personally don't see how this line is distinguished enough to be preserved. I'd write this line out, personally.

Really good job, here. Exceptional.

-Kylan

User avatar
Hannah
Review
Hannah wrote a review · Fri Jul 17, 2009 11:09 pm

Hey, bby. I'm finally here -- light years after you requested, but I'm still here. xD -nom-

I. Little Things

I could have put the urn on that but it might have slipped off the sloped back, and what a thing for our son to see on weekend mornings over his Cocoa Puffs.


I like all the detail you have in this sentence, but I think it needs to be reworked to read more smoothly. Do you think it would work just as well if you said 'over his weekend-morning Cocoa Puffs' instead? It's a bit clunky, but clearer at the same time. xD

and the muscles of my face ached under my new clamminess pinstriped skin,


Clammy is a good adjective for this sentence, but you've put it in wrong. oO; It doesn't really make sense the way you've phrased it, so rework it.

I thought: I do not want that mess of a face I saw in the mirror this morning caked on my bones like plaster, but rubbing at the lines with the heel of my palm made my wrist numb.


This sentence is beautiful once you go back and figure out what you're saying. If there's any way that you can rework this to make it clear, to divide the objects up so we know what the heck you're talking about, that would be much appreciated, since it's quality and I would love it to shine through.

I thought: I want to hold details of him like that in place, to sew his past to my eyelids, it will be worth wearing that mess of a face for; but the memory, so startling in its clarity, was already fading.


This sentence gets rather convoluted, too, but I don't think you even need to speak about the worth of wearing the face. It was a subject discussed earlier, and I think now you can stick with talking about the memories.

The rims of iris were too thin around those darkness-swollen pupils to resemble his father’s, though I knew William’s were the same pale blue, the color of deoxygenated blood.


This description was so beautiful. I really love it. xD

His dear old grandmother said


I don't know if this is meant to be kind of sarcastic or not, but since it's not obvious it kind of seems out of place. The rest of the description says that neither William nor Abigail like this woman, so I think it would probably be okay to just say 'his grandmother said' and leave the emotion for later explanation.

“But Dad gave me baths,” he said, which was true, which was why I hadn’t remembered before, and which might or might not have been a clever ploy to escape the unwanted ministrations but either way paused me there, halfway up.


Again, a confusing sentence. I think you should try to break it up. I realize that it's conversational, but it stops the reader because it's confusing at first, if they're in reading mode and not conversational mode. xD

I doubt it carried through his downed skin.


By 'downed', did you mean to give the image of softness? It came after some thought, but the first image was of skin going down or looking down, and I don't think that's what you were going for. :] Try a different word, perhaps. Downy? Downish?

I said, sketching smiles like fish on his breast pocket with my fingers as I dropped to his level.


Okay, I have to admit that I did not understand this sentence at all. oO; I don't get what she's sketching, or what it has to do with fish, and it leaves me in a mess, so I hope you can clear it up for me. xD

dipped my arm elbow-deep the hot greenish water,


You mention that the water is green twice in this piece, and at face value, that brings out an image of algae or dirty water. I know what green you're talking about though -- that beautiful blue-green that bath tub water sometimes gets when it's being drawn? I think you have to find a better way to describe it, though, so we don't think that there's a problem with the water in Abigail's house.

I’d taken my damper jeans off


First of all, would she have stayed wet that long? It seemed like she had a lot of time to dry off, even if not completely. Secondly, 'damper jeans' is kind of an awkward description, though I don't know how you could rework it to make it sound better.

II. Big Things

-- Description

I love you. You are a master at inserting beautiful, personal little bits of detail. Especially coming from this piece in first person, it really helps to add to characterization and the way the reader relates to the character as well. Just try to avoid longer, confusing sentences {when sometimes you try to cram more description in than the sentence can hold}, and you'll be fine.

-- Ending, Overall

Seriously, though, you're a genius. Whenever I try to delve into issues like this, I find that it comes off fake or unstudied, because I haven't really been through something like this. I don't know if you have, or if it's just that you have the talent to delve deeper into shallow emotions and find beauty like this, but you brought out the desperation and the poignant emotions that go with this kind of story. You don't even understand how beautiful it is. A story like this, I'd want to see published and famous. It's so gorgeous.

I'm so jealous.

PM me with more.

<3

-Hannah-

User avatar
Galerius
Comment

I shall critique this! ...soon.

Watch this spot.

Random avatar
sayaandtenshi Comment

I don't understand where her standing was with her husband's death. The way she spoke it sounded as if she didn't love her husband. And when you explained about how her mother-in-law seemed to like her I didn't understand her dislike toward her mother-in-law. This story, while well written, was very confusing. But I did like it.

Random avatar
sayaandtenshi Review

I don't understand where her standing was with her husband's death. The way she spoke it sounded as if she didn't love her husband. And when you explained about how her mother-in-law seemed to like her I didn't understand her dislike toward her mother-in-law. This story, while well written, was very confusing. But I did like it.

User avatar
Mira
Review
Mira wrote a review · Sun Jul 05, 2009 6:35 pm

Hiyas, Helpful McHelpfulpants! (love your name, by the way)

I'd have to say, this story was absolutely wonderful. You have a brilliant way of writing and I was just completely drawn into the story. I could barely find anything wrong, though I have a few nitpicks.

She stank of soap, detached herself from my ribcage reluctantly when I withdrew.


This sentence just seems funny to me. How does the smell of soap connect to her withdrawal?

I watched the dust settle for two minutes and seventeen seconds.


I don't think the specific time is necessary and it takes away from the story a bit. Perhaps if it was just "I watched the dust settle."?


Overall: Just amazing! I was really enthralled by this. Characters and description were both awesome. :) Keep up the good work!

Just one question. It kind of sounds as if this could go on. Are you planning on writing more or was this the entire thing? Either way works, but if you continue this, please PM me! :)

~Mira

User avatar
Lilicia
Review
Lilicia wrote a review · Sun Jul 05, 2009 9:55 am

This was amazing! Very descriptive and well written. Just a few things:

So after talking it over with his mother and my son the Tuesday following my husband’s death, I walked to the riverside carrying a balsawood box provided by the crematorium


This disturbed me: would you really talk over what to do with your husband's ashes with your eight year old son?

I thought: I do not want that mess of a face I saw in the mirror caked on my bones like plaster


I had to re-read this - it's confusing. When did she look in the mirror - and why was it caked on her bones like plaster? Please explain!

I understood, yeah.


Personally, I don't think the 'yeah' really fits in with the context. It's too casual for the sombre atmosphere.

Also, maybe you could speak a bit more about her relationship with Derek - did they love each other? Is she devastated by his death, or merely shocked?

Apart from that, it's perfect. I couldn't find any grammar or spelling mistakes - and I loved the ending!
Hope I helped! :)



It's hard to enjoy practical jokes when your whole life feels like one.
— Rick Riordan, The Last Olympian